An introduction to the analysis of self defense in criminal cases

On appeal of some of those cases, courts have reversed, suggesting that self-defense based on PTSD is a recognized phenomenon in case law. In cases in which an insanity defense based on PTSD was allowed, but in which the defendant was convicted and the case was appealed, appellate courts have in some cases upheld the rejection of the insanity defense by juries.

To this day, some people speculate that Halloran may have been the actual murderer and that An introduction to the analysis of self defense in criminal cases simply helped him cover it up.

Fields was found guilty. Percy, 21 a Supreme Court of Vermont case, a Vietnam veteran was accused of sexual assault and kidnapping, among other charges. Johnson was convicted of two cocaine sales charges. The Court, however, denied her request. Baker continued to work for Knight for the next two years and scandalous rumors began to spread that the two of them were involved in a sexual relationship.

Malice — The intention to do evil, inflict injury, or cause suffering of another. The court therefore reversed the conviction and remanded. Hines claimed self-defense, contending that she was sexually abused by her father as a child and that on the day of the offense he made sexual advances toward her and threatened her.

First described by Dr. Parasiris was charged with first-degree murder, but maintained that he only acted in self-defense to protect his family.

For instance, a defendant is justified in using force that is intended or likely to cause death or severe injury if someone violently enters his home, and he believes such force is necessary to prevent harm from coming to himself, or to another person in the home.

Sometime during the evening of August 27, Little escaped from the facility and the body of year-old jailer, Clarence Alligood, was found her in her cell.

Once the phrase "prosecutorial discretion" conjured up an image of sober, reflective and mature exercise of well-informed judgment, usually characterized by a certain concern for public confidence in the system. The same remedies are available to finance criminal prosecution as civil litigation.

Of note, Massachusetts employs the American Law Institute standard for insanity, in which a defendant is not considered criminally responsible if, as a result of mental disease or defect, the defendant lacked the capacity either to appreciate the criminality of his conduct or to conform his conduct to the requirements of the law.

Rezaq, 29 a District of Columbia district court case, the defendant was charged with aircraft piracy, for which he intended to present an insanity defense based on PTSD.

The DA is effectively immune. The habeas court denied his petition, holding that he had failed to show how PTSD was related to his offense. Wood, 58 a Illinois Circuit Court case, the defendant, again a Vietnam veteran, was found not guilty by reason of insanity in the shooting of the foreman in the factory where he worked.

At trial, a defense expert testified that Mr. The basic elements of self-defense are that the defendant is not the aggressor, the defendant reasonably fears imminent death or great bodily harm that necessitates the use of force to save his life, and the amount of force used by the defendant is reasonably necessary to avert the danger and not more than exigency demands.

10 Shocking Controversial Self-Defense Cases

Cope, 50 a federal case, the defendant received the maximum sentence for methamphetamine-related charges. Once the crowd started throwing rocks at the house and rushing towards it, shots were fired from the upstairs window.

Finally, for crimes in which PTSD played a role but did not amount to one of these defenses, some courts have found it to be a mitigating circumstance in sentencing.

Many private attorneys have criminal experience as former prosecutors or public defenders. However, in some cases PTSD has been found to be relevant to the criminal defenses of insanity, unconsciousness, self-defense, diminished capacity, and sentencing mitigation.

A congressional solution is necessary to truly curb the over-breadth of discretion and power given to individual lawyers who happen to hold the job of counsel for the government. The couple had been married for 31 years and had two sons together, but Nancy allegedly suffered through many incidents of spousal abuse.

PTSD as a Criminal Defense: A Review of Case Law

Wood was in a dissociative state. The court cited several cases supporting its opinion. Particular attention should be directed to whether PTSD phenomena that have been recognized by courts as relevant to criminal defenses were present.

However, nine of the rounds had gone through and through the attacker, and one over-penetrating bullet wounded the victim in the leg.

Self Defense

A review of appealed jury verdicts in cases in which self-defense based on PTSD was claimed reveals that conviction of a lesser included offense is another potential outcome of such cases.

Once someone uses excessive force, which is more force than the situation truly calls for, then he gives up his right of self defense.

Defenses to Criminal Charges

In some cases, people have used a self-defense claim to successfully get away with murder. She was convicted, but the appeals court reversed, ruling that the exclusion of PTSD testimony was an error.

To be sure, most prosecutors we encounter work long hours with little glory trying to bring about a just result. In summary, PTSD testimony has been allowed and has been found to be relevant and compelling by some appellate courts when offered in conjunction with a diminished capacity or related mens rea defense.

At present, many cases are never prosecuted for one reason or another. Right of Self Defense The right of self defense is the right for a person to use reasonable force to defend himself, his property, or the lives of others.

Other options are more promising.Self defense laws restrict the protections of such a defense for those who initiate the conflict. There are two ways a person can remain protected under self defense laws if he was the one to start the conflict.

Self Defense In Criminal Cases

6 Self-Defense Court Cases You Need To Know. 5 of 5 6 Self-Defense Court Cases You Need To Know. Comment(s) We possess firearms and perhaps even carry them on or about our persons in public for reasons of self-defense. Since the criminal gets the first move and has the advantage of picking the time and place of his attack, he is the actor.

Self-Defense in Criminal Cases This Essay Self-Defense in Criminal Cases and other 64,+ term papers, college essay examples and free essays are available now on Autor: review • December 22, • Essay • 2, Words (11 Pages) • Views4/4(1).

An Introduction to the Analysis of Self-Defense in Criminal Cases PAGES 9. WORDS 2, View Full Essay. More essays like this: self defense in criminal cases, states supreme court, private preparation of criminal cases.

Not sure what I'd do without @Kibin - Alfredo Alvarez, student @ Miami University. Exactly what I needed. The most common defenses are: self- defense and the insanity defense. Two cases that discuss various types of criminal defenses are the Andrea Yates case and the James Bryan Miller case.

The Andrea Yates case was a very disturbing case.

6 Self-Defense Court Cases You Need To Know

Robinson's attorney claims he killed his father in self-defense and deserved to be on house arrest while awaiting trial. Prosecutors say the father had not presented an immediate threat, and the.

An introduction to the analysis of self defense in criminal cases
Rated 4/5 based on 28 review